Valenti On The Moral Imperative (7.6 MB)
Very provocative speech by Jack Valenti, president of the MPAA. He makes a good defense of the MPAA’s actions, a defense that would endear itself to most Americans; however, I’d like to offer some thoughts to keep in mind while listening.
I couldn’t help but think, as Valenti opened his speech, “wait, wait - Hollywood is lecturing me on morality?”
Valenti never shows a terrible amount of concern for fair use, as evidenced in his responses to the questions of a backup copy, use of software to filter content in DVDs, or DVD region encodings.
He may not see any difference between having to purchase new glasses and wanting to NOT purchase a new DVD, but the Supreme Court has, and has ruled that backup copies are within fair use.
He speaks of the free market system, which, as he points out, can be manipulated by powerful people. He then says that a moral system must be crafted to uphold the free market system. What place is there for the consumer in Valenti’s moral system? Are there any consumer rights, or do all the rights (how many copies, what region it may be viewed in, what content must be viewed) belong to the producer?
Finally, history has shown us that law frequently lags behind the moral system, and during those times of lag, illegal activity is indeed a moral response. Our country began under such a notion, and has developed through difficult times under such a notion. Based on that, I feel no moral apprehension at violating the DMCA to invoke my rights to fair use.
written by Kyle
Recent Comments